← Back to Feed

Post from October 10, 2026

Your health check can correctly report a failure and still trigger the wrong response.

The intuitive standard for a health check is accuracy:

If something is wrong, it should say so.

That’s a reasonable starting point, but while reading an architectural article about health endpoint monitoring, I realized that accuracy alone doesn’t tell us what action the result should trigger.

Consider an application whose health check tests database connectivity, and whose result controls restarts. The database itself goes down. The check fails, so the application restarts. When it comes back up, the check fails again because the database is still unavailable.

The database connectivity test reported a real failure. But that result didn’t establish that the application needed restarting. Restarting it can’t bring the database back.

That’s the shift for me. When automation acts on a health check, it isn’t enough for the check to identify the system’s condition accurately. The result also has to support the action the automation takes in response. A check can be technically correct and still lead to the wrong outcome if it detects a real condition (the database is down) but doesn’t provide enough evidence to justify the response (restarting the app).

In this example, the database failure is still valuable information for diagnosing and alerting. It just doesn’t justify the automatic restart of the application.

So before connecting a health check to automation, review the conditions that can make it fail. For each one, ask: “What happens when this check fails, and why would that response help?”

Loading comments…